Wednesday, October 17, 2007

Criminal Minds

Something has gone horribly wrong with this show. Mandy Patinkin is gone this season, and that presents problems, but that's not the big deal. It's details, friends. Details. This show's integrity rests on the details. It's about a group of FBI agents that are major crimes/serial killer profilers. They do their work by anticipating and noticing the little things.

Here are two incidents from recent weeks which indict, I would guess, writing and post-production respectively.

1) An exchange between a parent and a child who is writing at the kitchen table:
PARENT: What are you working on?
CHILD: Multiplication.
PARENT (Startled and impressed): Multiplication!?!
CHILD: Yeah; it's for extra credit. The rest of the class is still on long division.

Think about it, chums. You can't do long division without multiplication. Am I wrong? If so, correct me, elementary teachers of the world.

2) A woman is having a conversation on a land-line telephone. She is speaking to a friend when she hears a busy signal. We learn later in that show that the conversation was interrupted because the line was cut. Apparently, a phone connected to nothing magically generates a busy signal. I understand that if you just have a line go dead, it doesn't tell the story. It just sounds like the other party stops talking. But I'm not sure that the fix to the problem is to use a factually inaccurate stand-in for silence.

This used to be a smart show, but it has rapidly moved off of my must-see list. Smart shows? Friday Night Lights and Numbers.

4 Comments:

At 7:10 AM, Blogger Galoot said...

I'm still having a hard time buying Rob Morrow as anything but his "Northern Exposure" character. Even "Quiz Show" stretched him a bit far. I haven't watched the second episode of "FNL" this season, but I hope that Landry killing the other dude gets resolved soon. I liked him more when he was just pining for Riggins' sloppy seconds.

 
At 9:57 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Give Morrow the chance he deserves. Numb3ers really is a great show and Rob does a good job leading the team.

FNL? I just hope Landry finds his watch!!!

 
At 8:29 AM, Blogger Steaming bowl o' Calderone said...

Steve Jones! You started posting again and I missed it. Dammit! Now you're off again on one of your self-imposed exiles and the world weeps silently.

 
At 11:59 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The writing in criminal minds definitely took a turn for the shallow from the very first of this season. They lost me by week 3. Good points about attention to detail. But if you think noisy dead phones are distracting, don't get me started about the myriad of non-existent computer technologies used every week in movies and television. America's finest can only dream of having such ground breaking technology at their disposal.

Kobster T. Lazy (as in too lazy to create a google account so he can post on his long lost high school friend's blog).

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

Google